Day 34 - The 100 Day Project: What Superforecasters Can Teach Us About Thinking and Decision-Making

Learn how to think like a superforecaster to improve your decision-making, foresight, and leadership skills through strategic reading.

We all forecast. Whether it’s choosing a career path, buying a home, or planning for the future of a business, we’re constantly making decisions based on how we think things might unfold. But most of us do it intuitively, guided more by gut feeling than structured reasoning. In Superforecasting, Philip Tetlock and Dan Gardner show us that there’s a better way. A more disciplined, thoughtful, and effective approach to anticipating the future.

This isn’t about crystal balls or extraordinary intuition. It’s about habits of thinking. And the good news is anyone can learn them.

Forecasting Is a Skill, Not a Gift

In a massive research project called the Good Judgment Project, Tetlock and his team discovered that some ordinary people, curious, open-minded, and analytical, were consistently better at making accurate predictions than experts, pundits, or even professional intelligence analysts with classified information.

These individuals were called superforecasters. What set them apart wasn’t brilliance or insider knowledge. It was how they approached forecasting:

They broke problems into smaller parts.
They challenged their own assumptions.
They thought in probabilities, not certainties.
They updated their beliefs when presented with new data.
They practiced relentlessly and learned from past mistakes.

These traits are both learnable and repeatable. In fact, Superforecasting makes it clear that excellence in thinking is cultivated through deliberate effort, not bestowed at birth.

Thinking Like a Superforecaster

Superforecasters possess what Tetlock describes as a "fox" mindset. This is a metaphor borrowed from the ancient Greek poet Archilochus: “The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing.” Foxes are eclectic thinkers, open to multiple perspectives, constantly questioning and updating. Hedgehogs, by contrast, cling tightly to one big idea and tend to ignore evidence that contradicts their worldview.

To improve your foresight, cultivate fox-like thinking. That means being comfortable with ambiguity, being intellectually humble, and willing to revise your conclusions.

Here are a few practical tools and mindsets that superforecasters use:

Fermi Estimates: Break complex questions down into simpler, more measurable parts. This technique helps separate what’s knowable from what’s not.
Bayesian Updating: Adjust your beliefs incrementally based on new evidence.
Thesis, Antithesis, Synthesis: Consider opposing viewpoints before arriving at a reasoned middle ground.
Postmortems: Reflect on your decisions, whether right or wrong, to improve your process going forward.
Dragonfly-Eye View: Integrate diverse perspectives and data sources to get a clearer picture of possible futures.

Why This Matters for Leaders

For CEOs, entrepreneurs, and anyone in a decision-making role, the implications are profound. In a world where the pace of change is accelerating, foresight is not optional. It’s a leadership skill.

Effective leaders are not expected to know the future, but they must be skilled at navigating uncertainty. By adopting the habits of superforecasters, leaders can:

Make better-informed strategic decisions.
Respond more effectively to emerging trends.
Avoid the pitfalls of overconfidence and groupthink.
Cultivate a culture of critical thinking and adaptive learning.

As the authors note, superforecasters are in perpetual beta, constantly refining their process, improving their judgment, and embracing the discomfort of not knowing. That’s a mindset every forward-thinking leader can benefit from.

The Limits of Prediction

Despite their skill, even the best forecasters face limits. Superforecasting acknowledges the reality of Black Swan events, unexpected, high-impact occurrences that no model or method can foresee. The Arab Spring, for example, was sparked by a single act of protest that triggered massive geopolitical upheaval. No algorithm could have predicted that.

So what’s the takeaway? While you can’t control or foresee everything, you can become better equipped to respond intelligently to what unfolds. As Tetlock puts it, “The future is not preordained. It is not foreseen. It is shaped by the choices you make now.”

Cultivating Foresight at AOLLA

At the Art of Learning Leadership Academy, we’re building a community of readers and thinkers who don’t just consume information. They apply it. Superforecasting is a perfect fit for the work we do, which is helping members read with purpose, act with intention, and lead with clarity.

Here’s how you can apply what you’ve learned today:

The next time you make a prediction, big or small, write it down.
Assign a probability to it.
Revisit it in a few weeks or months and reflect: Were you right? Why or why not?

That simple exercise puts you on the path to greater accuracy and insight.

Final Thoughts

Superforecasting isn’t just about better predictions. It’s about better thinking. It's about approaching the future not with fear, but with curiosity, discipline, and an openness to learning.

As part of #The100DayProject, this book stands out as a call to elevate how you think, not just what you think.

If you’re ready to train your foresight, improve your judgment, and lead with deeper insight.

Bookish Notes complement reading the book. And not a substitute. You’ll read the books faster because the Notes are so detailed. However, mastering strategic reading, which teaches you how to focus on what matters. The Applied Knowledge is Power workshop can help you.

👉 Join us at the Art of Learning Leadership Academy: AOLLA.info

[Join the Applied Knowledge is Power Workshop]

If you want access to my Bookish Notes, please consider joining my membership site, the Art of Learning.

This post contains affiliate links and The Invisible Mentor® may earn commissions for purchases made through links in this post. For more details, see here.

Categories: : Leadership development